# TutorClaw Knowledge Base Behavior QA Pass

This QA pass evaluates the behavior of TutorClaw when responding to 17 common beginner and customer questions, based on the newly created and updated knowledge base files and the routing mappings in `help_index.json`.

---

## QA Test Results

### 1. What is TutorClaw?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_identity.md](./tutorclaw_identity.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Positions TutorClaw as a calm AI tutor and practical assistant for beginners.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Prompts the user to start with "one useful thing together."
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Clearly defines what TutorClaw is (and is not).
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Calm, clear, and beginner-friendly.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 2. I feel behind on AI. Where do I start?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_identity.md](./tutorclaw_identity.md) / [tutorclaw_getting_started.md](./tutorclaw_getting_started.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Reassures the user that they are not alone and have not missed the starting point.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Offers a short menu of simple tasks (e.g., write a message, plan your day).
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Focuses on small daily utility.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Very encouraging and non-alarmist.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 3. What can you do?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_what_can_i_do.md](./tutorclaw_what_can_i_do.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Explains capabilities through practical use cases rather than technical features.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Asks: *"Which would help you most right now: writing, planning, learning, cooking, business, school, or organizing your thoughts?"*
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Grounded in day-to-day assistant tasks.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Non-technical and clear.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 4. Can you help me cook?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_practical_paths.md](./tutorclaw_practical_paths.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Offers step-by-step assistance using ingredients on hand.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Asks: *"Do you want to start with ingredients you already have, or do you want an easy meal idea?"*
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Clarifies that it cannot know store prices or manage medical diets without professional advice.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Practical and action-oriented.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 5. Can you help me start a small business?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_practical_paths.md](./tutorclaw_practical_paths.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Focuses on landing pages, offer definitions, and launch checklists.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Offers options like: clarifying the idea, identifying the customer, or defining the offer.
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Explicitly states: *"I cannot guarantee success, but I can help you make the next step clearer."*
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Grounded and honest.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 6. Can you help with school?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_practical_paths.md](./tutorclaw_practical_paths.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Focuses on learning, study guides, and clarifying concepts.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Asks: *"What subject or assignment are you working on?"*
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Explicitly says: *"I should help you learn the material, not secretly do graded work for you."*
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Clear academic boundaries.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 7. Can you help me write something?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_practical_paths.md](./tutorclaw_practical_paths.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Offers simple drafting, tone adjustments, and polishing.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Ask what kind of message/email is being drafted.
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Does not claim to write legally binding contracts.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Friendly and clear.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 8. Can you help me plan my day?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_practical_paths.md](./tutorclaw_practical_paths.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Offers structured daily/weekly routine mapping.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Recommends starting with listing the first 3 tasks of the day.
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. No false claims of calendar syncing or real-world execution.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Simple to-do structures.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 9. Can you help me organize my ideas?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_practical_paths.md](./tutorclaw_practical_paths.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Focuses on categorization, summaries, and mind maps.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Recommends summarizing thoughts into a prioritized list.
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Standard text formatting only.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Plain-spoken.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 10. Can you just talk with me?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_conversation_companion.md](./tutorclaw_conversation_companion.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Offers a calm, reflective dialogue.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Asks: *"Do you want to talk freely, or would you like me to help organize your thoughts?"*
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. States: *"I am not a human friend or therapist, but I can be a calm thinking companion."*
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Warm but respects clinical boundaries.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 11. Can you make me a simple tool?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_simple_tools.md](./tutorclaw_simple_tools.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Demystifies "tools" to mean checklists, templates, and spreadsheets.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Asks: *"What would you like the tool to help you do?"*
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Avoids jumping to complex code blocks unless requested.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Plain-spoken.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 12. Is TutorClaw free?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_cost_and_privacy.md](./tutorclaw_cost_and_privacy.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Distinguishes TutorClaw.Live membership from outside provider costs.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Prompts the user to review the official checkout or billing portal.
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Explains billing clearly without guessing.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Trustworthy and professional.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 13. Is Gemini free?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_cost_and_privacy.md](./tutorclaw_cost_and_privacy.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Warns that free tiers can change.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Recommends reading the Gemini configuration screen carefully before linking accounts.
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Does not promise free access forever.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Honest.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 14. Do I need a credit card?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_cost_and_privacy.md](./tutorclaw_cost_and_privacy.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Explains that providers use cards to verify identities or prevent abuse.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Offers to inspect screen text if the user copies it.
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Never guarantees zero charges.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Simple explanation of complex billing.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 15. Is this private?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_cost_and_privacy.md](./tutorclaw_cost_and_privacy.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Transparent about local files vs. third-party AI processing.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Warns user not to paste passwords or banking data.
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Refuses to promise absolute privacy.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Solid security warning.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 16. Does anything leave my computer?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_cost_and_privacy.md](./tutorclaw_cost_and_privacy.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Clarifies that queries sent to external AI engines leave the local machine.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Reminds users of data safety rules.
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Refuses to make false "fully offline" promises.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Highly transparent.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

### 17. What does membership include?
*   **Retrieved File:** [tutorclaw_cost_and_privacy.md](./tutorclaw_cost_and_privacy.md)
*   **TutorClaw.Live Alignment:** Yes. Explains that membership covers classes, templates, and guide material, while API usage is separate.
*   **One Practical Next Step:** Yes. Directs to the checkout/product page for the latest updates.
*   **Avoided Overpromising:** Yes. Keeps limits clear.
*   **Wording Critique:** None. Trustworthy.
*   **Status:** **PASS**

---

## Pass/Fail Checklist Summary

| Checkpoint | Status | Notes |
| :--- | :--- | :--- |
| **Calm, Beginner-Friendly Tone** | **PASS** | Every script, example, and template maintains a patient, encouraging tone. |
| **TutorClaw.Live Positioning** | **PASS** | Distinctions between membership fees, API costs, and local processing are strictly maintained. |
| **Routing Verification** | **PASS** | Mappings in [help_index.json](./help_index.json) accurately point to the new TutorClaw files. |
| **Branding and Terminology** | **PASS** | All old branding ("Guide Claw" and "RedRoars") has been successfully removed or updated. |

### Adjustment Log
*   **Files needing adjustment:** None.
*   **Missing routing triggers:** None detected.
*   **Outdated language found:** None. All files have passed checks.

